Ten of the Most Common Mistakes Made by Companies When They Are Fitting Out Their Office
Office fit-outs represent a major capital expenditure. The decisions made during the course of this process will significantly determine how effective your workplace will function in the future.
Many people think about the physical space after the construction phase of a fit-out has been completed. In fact, the majority of critical decision-making occurs prior to commencement of actual construction.
A meeting room may appear spacious on a floor plan; however, once furniture is placed in the space, the room may seem small. New partitions could obstruct access to pre-existing building service systems. Changes that are perceived to be relatively minor in terms of design could result in additional costs (materials), and/or delays to install.
All of the previously mentioned examples are the types of things that can easily be overlooked while focusing on creating a new workplace.
Regardless of whether you are moving into a newly built property or renovating/fitting out an existing office, identifying these 10 common errors can assist you in making better-informed decisions and avoid potential complications in relation to the project.
1. Designing the Space Before Determining How Your Company Will Function Within That Space
It is likely that your initial thoughts about designing a new office will include ideas about how you would like the space to look. While an aesthetically pleasing office does not automatically equate to a productive workspace, there are several key factors that need to be determined regarding the functionality of your new office space. Prior to determining where specific elements such as desks, meeting rooms and shared workspaces will be located, you must first identify how your business currently utilizes space.
One example to illustrate the differences between companies includes the following: One company may employ a large number of staff who each spend the majority of their time at individual workstations. Another company may consist of multiple teams that regularly collaborate via video conferencing, attend client meetings or participate in other forms of group collaboration. Both companies may have an equal number of employees; however, based on their respective operational structures, their space utilization requirements may differ greatly.
Some questions to ask yourself:
How many employees typically occupy the office at peak periods?
Which departments need to work collaboratively?
Where are employee confidential conversations taking place?
Are all meeting rooms consistently booked up?
What type of storage facilities, technical/equipment-related support and other back-of-house areas are necessary?
One method of determining how best to utilize your available space is by evaluating how effectively your existing workplace is functioning. Identify the issues that employees face every day while they are performing their duties.
The takeaway: Determine the daily activities occurring in the office to drive the layout, versus attempting to force those activities into a predetermined design.
2. Undervaluing Acoustic Performance & Employee Privacy
Collaborative workplaces can foster greater communication among team members and make optimal use of floor space; however, due to the proximity of different activities, they create challenges for employees who require quieter environments to perform their tasks. For instance, a colleague discussing an issue with another colleague may be acceptable in a collaborative area; however, this discussion could be disrupting the concentration of a team member working on a highly complex assignment in close proximity.
In addition, an office featuring glass walled meeting rooms may provide a visually appealing feature without offering sufficient speech privacy for sensitive discussions that require confidentiality.
To address the issues related to acoustics and employee privacy, consideration must be given to acoustic performance as part of the overall layout design and not solely as a matter of addressing finishes post-construction. This may include:
Placing collaborative work areas near work zones with high concentrations of employees.
Designating enclose spaces for private conversations/video conferences.
Choosing partitions, doors and ceiling assemblies with adequate acoustic performance.
Assessing how sound transfers from adjacent rooms and through ceiling cavities.
Additionally, it is essential to acknowledge that acoustic absorption and soundproofing serve different purposes. An aesthetic acoustic panel used in conjunction with a decorative finish may improve the sound quality within a particular room by reducing reverberation, yet fail to prevent conversations from being audible in adjacent areas.
The takeaway: Consider where noise-generating activities occur, where employee privacy is necessary and how these two competing interests can be reconciled prior to finalizing the layout.
3. Ignoring Constraints Imposed by Pre-Existing Building Services
Even though an office appears flexible, especially when an expansive open floor area exists, several factors exist behind walls and above ceilings that will impact what is feasible. Air conditioning systems, lighting fixtures, electric infrastructure, fire safety systems and communications/data services all need to interact with proposed layout designs.
For example, if numerous enclosed offices were inserted into an otherwise open-floor-space configuration, this could alter how conditioned air circulates throughout that space.
In addition, installing several new partitions may also restrict placement or effectiveness of existing sprinklers, smoke detectors and emergency lights. These restrictions can have an effect upon both design and amount of work required.
Therefore, early investigation should define which services can continue unaltered, which services will need modifications, and where specialized assistance will be required.
The takeaway: Assess pre-existing building systems before establishing a final layout design. A successful design on paper requires success in harmony with the building.
4. That All Internal Alterations Will Qualify for Exemption From Building Consent (And Other Issues)
Not every office fit-out in NZ requires building consent; however, assuming that all internal changes are exempt is a potentially expensive error.
As per the Building Act, certain types of internal alterations to existing non-residential buildings do not require building consent providing they meet the exemptions outlined in the Act.
However, work to any structural element, specified system (fire alarm/sprinkler) or wall(s) will likely need building consent.
The Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment provide information regarding the guidelines for internal alterations to non-residential buildings.
Additionally, regardless of whether building consent is required or not, any building work performed on the premises will have to comply with the Building Code and any other relevant laws/legislation.
Leased premises add further complexities.
Typically leases detail what alterations can be made (if any), if written approval is required by the landlord prior to commencing and what obligations exist upon completion of the tenancy.
Another potential issue that many miss is the make-good provision. This usually means tenants will have to remove various improvements installed during their occupancy and restore the premises to its original state at the conclusion of their tenancy.
Understanding your obligations prior to installation of extensive partitions, specialist joinery or other permanent features can assist in avoiding future financial surprises.
Takeaway: Obtain consent requirements, landlord approvals and lease obligations early in the process using appropriately experienced professional assistance if necessary.
5. The Fit-Out Cost – But Not the Full Cost of the Project
Fit-out budgets are typically determined based solely on the estimated construction cost of the project.
This may account for a significant proportion of the overall expenditure; however, it does not account for the entire expense involved in creating a functional place of employment.
Additional expenses related to projects could include:
Design, engineering and consent associated fees.
Furniture and workstation equipment.
Cable data installations including networking and AV installations.
Access control and security systems.
Removal, relocation and storage of previous furniture.
Expenses incurred in moving personnel and/or temporary workplace arrangements.
Any additional works due to unforeseen site conditions.
Businesses may also wish to consider how flexible the budget may be.
For instance, finding out that an existing service will need to be modified may force the business to choose either additional expenditure or compromise on another aspect of the fit-out.
Budgets should reflect what is essential, what would be nice to have added and what could possibly be delayed if necessary. A realistic budget should also contain a sufficient contingency based on the risk and uncertainty inherent in the project.
Takeaway: Consider the full cost to create a working workplace, rather than just build the interior.
6. Evaluating Contract Quotes Based Solely On Price
Obtaining quotes from multiple contractors is a normal part of determining who will undertake your commercial fit-out. However, the lowest quote price does not always mean the most beneficial option.
Two contractors may seem to be quoting for similar scope-of-works yet have completely different presumptions regarding what is included.
A contractor may include removal of existing fixtures, protection of retained finishes and final clean-up into one quote. Another contractor may exclude these items from their quote.
Contractors may also vary in regards to materials specified, amount of electrical work included, level of project supervision and coordination of specialized trades.
Without reviewing each detail, businesses run the risk of comparing prices for entirely different scopes of work.
Prior to making a selection, compare:
Scope: Are both quotes based on the same drawings/specifications?
Inclusions/Exclusions: What has been included/excluded in each quote?
Materials/Finishes: Is each product quoted being used equivalently?
Delivery: Who will manage trade procurement, purchasing and site activities?
Allowances: Are there any costs that are provisional or requiring additional research/investigation?
If quotes differ substantially, understanding why may be far more important than assessing the difference in dollar amounts.
Takeaway: Evaluate what you are getting versus what you are paying for.
7. Waiting too long to make Furniture, Storage and Technology Decisions
Often furniture and technology are considered items that you select after most of your build-out has taken place. However, both can have a significant impact on the overall floor plan (layout) and required building systems (infrastructure).
For example, consider designing a conference/meeting room, but not having confirmed what type(s), model(s) and quantity of audio-visual equipment will be used. The final installation may require additional electrical outlets, conduit/cable routing/connections, reinforced walls, etc., and/or modification to the furniture placement. Similarly, the height/dimensions of each workstation will also determine the amount of circulation space in an open-office environment; where electrical outlets are placed; and how many individual workstations can be located in the same general area.
Storage needs are often significantly under estimated by designers. Without sufficient storage for documents, supplies/stationery, company equipment, employee personal effects, etc., common-use areas will soon become congested. Even very minor decisions (e.g. placing printers, lockers or shared storage areas) can greatly effect how people navigate an office.
So, furniture, technology and storage should be planned along with the spatial layout and building systems, rather than being "added-on" at some later point.
8. Making Design Changes Can Have Consequences
Design changes are part of the process in just about every fit out. Some design changes will improve the end product; some will resolve issues that were not identified until after the construction process started.
It's when those changes are made without considering their impact, that problems arise. For instance, moving a wall (partition) is relatively easy. However, if the timing of the move depends upon how far along the construction process is then many things could potentially be impacted by the change such as flooring, ceiling material, lighting fixtures, electrical receptacles and other materials which have been previously purchased.
Therefore one small change could affect multiple areas of your project. The longer you wait to introduce a change into the project process, the more time-consuming and complicated it may become. A good method for controlling these types of decisions is to define where approvals for design changes need to occur and designate someone within your organization to make the ultimate decision.
Additionally, prior to implementing any changes to the original plans (scope), understand what costs may incur with the new design changes (cost), determine how the changes may affect your projects' schedule (programme) and document all of this information.
9. Considering Normal Workplace Operations during Construction
Construction and day-to-day operations must be addressed when a company will be renovating an occupied space. The renovations could create problems that impact both employees and clients. This could include disruptions from noise, dust, limited accessibility, and/or interference with required functions of the business. Even if the renovation will occur prior to the client occupying the renovated space, it still possible to have limitations placed upon delivery of materials, elevator usage, use of loading docks or hours of operation, especially if the building has multiple tenants. These limitations could ultimately determine what time frame and manner the renovations are done.
When an organization is undertaking construction within an occupied facility, consideration should be made for creating a safe distance from the construction site and employees, ensuring access to the employees, and establishing responsibility among all parties involved. In New Zealand, the Health & Safety at Work Act provides that organizations who share H&S obligations shall consult with each other, cooperate with each other, and coordinate their actions to the extent feasible. Notwithstanding, the goal is not always to remove every disruption. Some level of disruption may be inevitable. Rather than focus on eliminating all disruptions, the goal is to recognize areas where disruptions could arise and take steps to mitigate those disruptions before they impact critical business operations.
The bottom line: Identify ongoing business operations, access to the building and worker safety as key elements of your project requirements, rather than items to resolve after you begin construction. For additional information about minimizing business disruptions due to office renovations click here for our article on "How To Minimize Business Disruptions Due To An Office Renovation".
10. Treating Construction Completion as the End of the Project
Treating completion of construction as the end of the project is misleading since an office (or space) completed on time does not mean it is ready to function with employees using it. In fact, most likely there will be additional items such as testing of systems, installation of furniture, configuration of equipment, etc., and minor defect repairs prior to the first employee occupying the office. For example, a meeting room could be fully constructed and ready to go but not functional until all the connections, audio visual equipment and ventilation have been inspected. Additionally, recently installed doors, access control, and/or lighting systems may need fine-tuning at this stage. A defined hand-over process would include consideration of outstanding defects along with responsibility for their correction; testing and commissioning of applicable building services; completing all necessary inspections, documentation, and approvals; access cards/keys/security arrangement details; operating/maintenance information for the facilities and/or systems; final cleaning, furniture placement and workstation preparation. It is often beneficial to evaluate how well a space works when employees are actually working out of it. Only then do some "practical" issues arise from using meeting rooms, work stations, and common areas as they were intended. The take away here: make the hand over process and preparing the facility to be operable part of your project scope right from the start versus just finalizing administrative procedures.
A Successful Office Fit-out Is About More Than the Finished Space
An Office fit-out includes much more than just choosing finishes and designing a new configuration.
The Office fit-out will combine the needs of the company with the restrictions of the property, the cost implications and the physical work that will be necessary in order to produce a working area.
Most of the errors listed above are very hard to correct after the construction process has begun.
Identifying the structure (building), verifying the parameters of the project, organizing specialty requirements and defining the roles of each party involved can all assist in managing the process better.
Ultimately, measuring the success of an Office fit-out is about how well the final completed space will function as an environment for the individuals who will use the space as well as how it functions in supporting their activities.
Are you looking to plan an Office fit-out?
Cemac commercial interiors assists clients, architects, designers, project managers and others in delivering commercial interiors projects including both new fit-outs and refurbished buildings.
From interior construction and partitions to furniture and practical solutions for workplaces, cemac’s goal is to help connect the disparate components of a commercial interior project.
If you’re thinking of a new Office fit-out or are making changes to your current workplace please feel free to contact us to discuss your project.